Sandra came because Sandra cared, more than she cared about anything, how she looked to the town. The devoted stepmother. She’d volunteered as a parent chaperone — not for me, I didn’t even know she was coming — so that people would see her being supportive, probably while telling the other parents how she’d “treated herself” to a prom dress for me after all. She was standing at the edge of the gym in the bag-with-the-tag energy of a woman performing generosity she’d never shown.
I walked in on a friend’s arm in my mother’s jeans, and I watched Sandra’s face do the thing I’ll keep forever: she saw the dress, she recognized the denim — she knew those were “those old jeans from the attic” — and she laughed. A real one. She said something to the mom next to her and laughed, at me, at the dress, at the whole homemade sight of it.
And about an hour into the night, the music stopped.
The DJ cut it. And Mr. Barnett, the principal, walked out onto the middle of the gym floor with a microphone, and the whole room went quiet and turned, and he started walking — across the gym, through the parting crowd — toward the edge where Sandra stood.
For one second she lit up. I watched her assume it was about her. The chaperone. The recognition.
“Before the next song,” Mr. Barnett said, “I want to tell you about a dress.”
And he told them. All of it, in a fifteen-year-old’s own words, because Jamie’s designer statement was right there in his hand. A boy who taught himself to sew on his late mother’s machine. Who made this gown, the one that just won our entire design showcase, out of four pairs of his mom’s old jeans. For his sister. “Because,” Mr. Barnett read, and his voice was very steady, “‘someone spent the money our mom left us for this, and told my sister nobody wants to watch her play at being a princess. But my mom wrote proms in her letter. So I made the princess part myself.’”
The gym had gone completely silent.
And Mr. Barnett, who had been walking the whole time, stopped — right in front of Sandra. The whole room’s eyes followed, and landed on her, and in that second every parent in that town understood exactly who “someone” was.
“We’d like Erin to come up,” Mr. Barnett said, not to her, past her, to me. “And her brother Jamie, who I’m told is here tonight. The judges would like to give him his award in person.”
The applause started somewhere in the back and became the loudest thing I’ve ever stood inside.
And Sandra stood alone in the middle of it, in her performance of a dress she never bought, exposed in front of the entire town she’d built her whole image for — not by me, not by Jamie, but by her own laugh, an hour earlier, at the best thing two motherless kids had ever made.
Chapter 5: Two Stars
Jamie came up out of the crowd in his one good shirt, mortified and fifteen and glowing, and Ms. Pryce handed him the showcase award, and the gym stood up. My brother, who’d been laughed out of the thing he loved by the woman at the edge of the room, got it back in front of everyone, all at once.
We danced. In our mother’s jeans. The stars at the hem caught the lights.
Sandra left early. There wasn’t a version of that night she could stay in.
I’d love to tell you we marched home and threw her out, but it was slower and more real than that. What the night actually did was get the right adults looking. Ms. Pryce, it turns out, is a mandated reporter who had just heard, in a child’s own handwriting, that a guardian had taken money a dead mother left in a documented account, with a letter, for her children. The school’s safeguarding lead got involved. So did our mom’s sister, our aunt Ruth, who lived two states away and had been quietly frozen out by Sandra since the funeral and had no idea how bad it had gotten.
The money had a paper trail — Mom’s letter, the savings account records, the dates Sandra drained it. Aunt Ruth got us a lawyer. I won’t pretend it was instant, but a woman who spends a dead mother’s children’s savings on handbags, with the mother’s own letter existing in a drawer, does not come out of that well. The money was recovered into trust for us where Sandra can’t reach it. And Jamie and I, by the end of that year, were living with Aunt Ruth, who cried when she saw the dress and asked if she could hang it up.
It hangs in Ruth’s house now, on a dress form in the front room, where she shows it to absolutely everyone who comes over, whether they ask or not.
Jamie’s back. All the way back. He’s in every design and textiles thing his new school offers, Ms. Pryce writes him recommendation letters, and he talks about fashion school the way he used to talk before Sandra got her hands on his sketchbook. The gift she laughed out of him is the thing that’s going to be his whole life, and I get to watch.
Our mom put forty dollars a month aside for eleven years and wrote the word “proms” in a letter, and a stepmother thought she could take all of it.
She took the money for a while. She never for one second had the thing the money was actually for.
Because my brother made the princess part himself, out of our mother’s jeans, on our mother’s machine, with a line of little stars along the hem.
Two stars. That’s what Mom called us.
We still are.
See more on the next page