He put his face in his hands.
He was not crying but he was close to it and he was deciding whether to be close to it or to pull back, the specific negotiation of a fourteen-year-old boy with his emotions in front of his mother.
I let him negotiate it without helping him.
“I think,” he said finally, “I need to apologize to him.”
“To Sam,” I said.
“Yes,” he said. “Is that possible? Can I go back?”
I thought about this.
“I think that’s possible,” I said. “I’ll call the restaurant tomorrow and explain the situation and see if Sam would be willing to receive an apology.”
“You’d do that with me?” he said.
“We’d do it together,” I said.
He nodded.
“What if he doesn’t want to see me?” Leo said.
“Then we respect that,” I said. “An apology is for the person being apologized to, not for the person apologizing. If Sam doesn’t want to receive it, that’s his right and we honor it.”
“And if he does?” Leo said.
“Then you tell him the truth,” I said. “Not the full story. He doesn’t need the full story. But you tell him what you did was wrong and that you’re sorry.”
“Without making it about me,” Leo said.
“Without making it about you,” I said.
He was quiet for a moment.
“Can I look at these?” he said, gesturing at the photographs.
“Yes,” I said.
He went through them slowly, picking each one up and looking at it before setting it down, in the careful way he handled things that mattered to him.
“He really was funny,” Leo said, looking at one of them.
“Which one?” I said.
“This one,” he said. He held up the photograph from the birthday party, the one where Danny was laughing at something outside the frame.
“He laughed like that for real,” I said. “With his whole body.”
“What was funny?” Leo said.
“I don’t remember,” I said. “Something his friend Marcus said, probably. Marcus always made him laugh.”
“Marcus,” Leo said. “Like my friend Marcus.”
“Yes,” I said. “Danny’s Marcus was different. He had known Danny since they were both teenagers. He gave the eulogy at Danny’s funeral.”
“What did he say?” Leo said.
I thought about Marcus at the lectern, forty-one years old and holding a single piece of paper that he had written on both sides.
“He said Danny made him better at being a person,” I said. “He said he had known Danny for twenty-five years and in that time he had watched Danny navigate things that would have made Marcus give up, and do it with a specific combination of stubbornness and grace that he had never seen in anyone else. He said he was embarrassed by how much he had learned from someone people mostly pitied, and that the embarrassment was good because it meant he had been paying attention.”
Leo was looking at the photograph.
“Twenty-five years,” he said.
“They met when they were fifteen,” I said. “Danny died at thirty-two. They were best friends for seventeen years, and then Marcus kept being his friend after he died, which is a thing that is possible to do.”
“How?” Leo said.
“You just keep living like someone would have wanted you to,” I said. “Marcus volunteers twice a month at the community center where they met. He has been doing it for eleven years.”
Leo set the photograph down.
“Mom,” he said.
“Yes.”
“I’m going to be different about this,” he said.
“Different how?” I said.
“Not just because of tonight,” he said. “I mean, because of tonight. But also because of Danny. Because I didn’t know and now I know and I can’t un-know.”
I looked at my son.
“That’s the right way to think about it,” I said.
“I wish I’d known him,” he said.
“I wish you had too,” I said.
I picked up the photograph from my graduation, Danny’s hand on my arm.
“He would have liked you,” I said. “The reading especially. He would have had opinions about your book opinions and he would not have held back.”
“I would have liked that,” Leo said.
“Yes,” I said. “You would have.”
We called the restaurant the next morning.
I explained the situation to the manager, who was a woman named Patricia, and I explained what had happened and what Leo wanted to do about it and why. She listened with the patience of someone who has seen many things in the business and this was different from most of them.
“Let me talk to Sam,” she said.
She called me back an hour later.
“Sam says he didn’t see anything,” she said. “He wasn’t aware of what the boy was doing.”
“I know,” I said. “That’s part of what Leo needs to reckon with.”
“He wants to come?” she said.
“He does,” I said.
A pause.
“Sam says that’s fine,” Patricia said. “Come Monday afternoon before we open. I’ll be here.”
We went on Monday afternoon.
Leo was wearing a button-down shirt, which he had chosen himself without my saying anything about what to wear, which told me something about how he was thinking about the occasion.
Sam was in the restaurant with Patricia when we arrived, setting tables, because that was apparently one of his responsibilities before service.
He looked up when we came in.
Leo walked toward him.
He did not have anything prepared. I had suggested he not prepare anything specific, that prepared words tended to sound like prepared words and that an apology was about honesty rather than performance, and he had thought about this and agreed.
He stopped in front of Sam.
“I was here Friday,” Leo said. “With my mom. You were our waiter.”
Sam looked at him.
“I remember,” Sam said.
“When you were reading the specials,” Leo said, “I was being disrespectful. I was making fun of you to my friend over text and I was doing something with my body that was imitating you in a mean way.”
Sam was quiet.
“You didn’t see it,” Leo said. “But I wanted you to know that I knew, and that I know it was wrong, and that I’m sorry.”
Sam looked at him for a long time.
I was watching from near the door, far enough away to give them the space the conversation required.
“Why are you telling me now?” Sam said.
“Because my mom showed me some photographs of my uncle Danny,” Leo said. “He had Down syndrome. He died before I was born. I never knew about him, and she showed me, and I understood that what I did to you was something that had been done to him, and it wasn’t right when it was done to him either.”
“What was his name?” Sam said.
“Danny,” Leo said.
Sam nodded.
“I’ve had people do what you did,” Sam said.
“I know,” Leo said.
“It’s not okay,” Sam said.
“No,” Leo said. “It’s not.”
Sam looked at Leo for a moment more.
“Thank you for coming,” Sam said. “You didn’t have to do that.”
“I wanted to,” Leo said.
“Okay,” Sam said.
He put out his hand.
Leo shook it.
We drove home.
Leo was quiet in the car, which was his way of processing, the same quiet he had always had after significant things, and I drove without filling the silence because the silence was doing something necessary.
When we were almost home he said: “He was kind about it.”
“Yes,” I said.
“More kind than I deserved,” he said.
“People often are,” I said.
He was quiet for another moment.
“I’m going to think about that,” he said. “What Sam said. That he had had people do that to him. People do that and then they go home and they don’t think about it again. And Sam has to keep working and keep smiling and keep reading the specials back because he wants to get it right.”
“Yes,” I said.
“And Danny had to keep going to the movie theater and selling tickets and knowing that sometimes the people he was helping were laughing at him,” he said.
“Yes,” I said.
“I don’t know how they do it,” he said.
“I asked Danny once,” I said. “When he was older, not when we were kids. I asked him how he dealt with it.”
“What did he say?” Leo said.
“He said he didn’t think about those people,” I said. “He said he thought about the good days, the days when everything worked and someone told him he’d done a great job, and he thought about Marcus, and he thought about what he was going to watch that night.”
“He just didn’t let it in,” Leo said.
“It wasn’t that simple,” I said. “He had bad days. He got frustrated and sad. But he had a practice of returning to the good things, and the practice held.”
Leo was looking out the window.
“I want to keep the photographs,” he said. “If that’s okay.”
“They’re yours,” I said.
I had decided this the previous night, looking at the wooden box on the kitchen table, that the photographs should move out of the back of the closet and into Leo’s life, that Danny should be present to him going forward in whatever way photographs could make a person present.
“I’ll put one on my desk,” Leo said.
“Which one?” I said.
“The movie theater one,” he said. “He looks like himself in that one.”
“He does,” I said.
We pulled into the driveway.
Leo didn’t move immediately to get out of the car.
“Mom,” he said.
“Yes.”
“What do you miss most about him?” Leo said.
I thought about it.
There were many things and choosing one felt like reducing something that resisted reduction, but I knew the answer that was most true.
“His opinions,” I said. “He had opinions about everything, and they were always his own. He never said what he thought he was supposed to say. He said what he actually thought, and sometimes it was surprising and sometimes it was exactly right and sometimes it was both.”
“He sounds like someone I would have liked,” Leo said.
“Yes,” I said. “He does.”
Leo got out of the car.
He held the door for a moment.
“Can you tell me more about him?” he said. “Not all at once. Just more. Over time.”
“Yes,” I said. “Over time.”
He went inside.
I sat in the car for a moment.
I thought about Danny, the way I often thought about him, in the moments that called for it. I thought about the movie theater photograph and the birthday party photograph and the graduation photograph, the specific quality of his laugh, the sound of it, which was one of the things photographs could not hold.
I thought about Marcus at the lectern with the paper written on both sides.
He made me better at being a person.
I thought about Leo shaking Sam’s hand.
I thought about the wooden box in the back of the closet and the twenty years I had carried it there without opening it, and the Friday evening in a restaurant when my son gave me a reason that I had not expected but perhaps had been waiting for.
Danny had been thirty-two.
He had worked at the movie theater for eleven years.
He had been loved completely.
He had never not been worth knowing.
The knowing of him, even secondhand, even through photographs and stories and a wooden box, was changing my son, was contributing to the becoming that was still in progress, was adding to the boy who sat with lonely kids at birthday parties the understanding of why he sat with them.
This was not the lesson I had planned to teach on a Friday evening in June when I took my son to the steakhouse to celebrate his report card.
It was the lesson that was necessary.
I got out of the car.
I went inside.
On the kitchen table, the photographs were where we had left them, spread out across the surface, and Leo had already taken the movie theater one, which I could see was no longer in the arrangement.
I gathered the rest back into the box.
I thought about where to put it now.
I thought it did not belong in the back of the closet anymore.
I put it on the bookshelf in the living room, where there were other things that mattered, and I straightened it slightly and stepped back and looked at it there.
Outside the window the June evening was finishing itself, the long light going horizontal the way it does at the end of a June day, and in his room Leo was doing something, reading probably, and on his desk there was a photograph of a man in a movie theater uniform who had laughed with his whole body at things that were genuinely funny, who had opinions about films that he expressed without reservation, who had been loved completely.
Danny.
Who my son now knew.
Who, in some way that I believe in even though I cannot explain it, now knew Leo.
See more on the next page