Everyone laughed at what she left me. Then I pressed PLAY, and the grandmother I thought I knew started telling me things she’d never said out loud.
Part 1: The Tape With My Name on It
“That’s it? That’s all she left you?”
My cousin didn’t even try to hide her laugh.
I looked down at the thing in my hand. A gray cassette tape. A faded paper label. And in one corner, in my grandmother’s handwriting, a single word: PENNY.
“I guess so,” I said.
The lawyer cleared his throat and kept reading.
Grandma’s apartment went to her children. Her jewelry was split among my cousins, along with a few modest checks. The pearl necklace she wore to church every Sunday. The gold bracelet that always snagged on her cardigan. The earrings she used to put on for my grandfather’s birthday dinners, back when he was still alive to see them.
I hadn’t expected anything valuable. I really hadn’t.
But I’d hoped for something familiar. Her recipe box, maybe. The little ticking clock from her kitchen. Something I could hold and remember her by.
Instead, I got a cassette.
“Maybe there’s a secret fortune hidden on it,” my cousin teased.
I slid the tape back into its envelope without answering.
Grandma Penny had been gone eight days. I was still waking up on Sunday mornings and reaching for my phone before I remembered there was no one left to call. I didn’t have the strength to defend her choices to anyone.
When the meeting ended, the lawyer asked me to stay behind.
The others filed out. One cousin lingered by my chair just long enough to say, “Let us know if she mentions anything interesting.”
The door clicked shut.
“Shannon,” the lawyer said, sitting down across from me, “your grandmother left me very specific instructions. She wanted you to listen to that tape alone.”
“Why?”
“She didn’t say.”
“Then how do you know that’s what she wanted?”
“Because she made me promise to repeat her exact words.” He glanced at a small note in his file.
“Listen alone. And don’t trust anyone who asks what’s on it.”
I stared at him. “She actually said that?”
“Word for word.”
“Do you know what’s on it?”
“No. She only asked me to make sure it got to you.”
I turned the envelope over in my hands. “Did she ever explain why I didn’t get anything else?”
He looked down at the file. “That was her decision, Shannon. I can’t tell you what she was thinking.”
Outside, my cousins were gathered by their cars, debating which pieces of jewelry needed cleaning. One of them called my name.
I pretended I didn’t hear.
Grandma and I had always been close. For as long as I can remember, she was my person.
When I was little, I spent whole weekends at her apartment. She kept a spare cardigan in the guest room just for me, because I always got cold after helping in her garden. We baked on Saturdays. Planted flowers every spring. Went to church together on Sundays.
As I got older, our routines changed, but the visits never stopped. Sometimes I tagged along to bingo with her and her friends. Sometimes we walked through the park. Sometimes we sat in her kitchen reading two different books and barely said a word, and it was perfect.
My cousins came on holidays. They weren’t bad people. They had jobs, kids, busy lives. They just weren’t there the way I was.
Then Grandma got sick.
During her last hospital stay, I visited every morning before work to read her the newspaper. In the evenings, I brought whatever novel we were reading together. Near the end, she couldn’t follow the story anymore. One night I reached the bottom of a page and realized she’d fallen asleep.
I kept reading anyway.
So driving home from the lawyer’s office, I couldn’t stop thinking about that tape. Not because I wanted money. I just wanted something of hers I could actually use. Something that didn’t require hunting down a machine from another century.
At home, I set the envelope on the kitchen table and called my mom.
“A cassette?” she repeated.
“Yes.”
“Well. Penny was never predictable.”
“Did you know?”
“No, sweetheart.”
“Why would she do that?”
“I don’t know.” I heard dishes clinking in the background. “Are you upset?”
I looked at the envelope. “A little.”
“That’s understandable.”
I loved her for that. She didn’t tell me the tape must be priceless in some deep, sentimental way. She just let me be disappointed.
After we hung up, I opened the hall closet.
When we’d sorted through Grandma’s things, I’d asked to keep her old cassette player. Nobody else wanted it. I took it because I remembered her playing music while she baked. It was still sitting in the grocery bag I’d carried it home in.
I set it on the table. Plugged it in. Pushed in the tape marked SIDE A.
I pressed PLAY.
For a moment, there was only a soft mechanical whir.
Then a child’s voice shouted, “I planted a flower!”
I froze.
It was me.
Not the voice I have now. A little girl’s voice, high-pitched and impatient.
Then came Grandma’s laugh. “What kind of flower, Shannon?”
“The purple kind.”
“Well, that narrows it down.”
“The one with the purple.“
“Oh. That one.”
I laughed out loud in my empty kitchen.
I must have been about six. I could see it all: the garden behind her apartment, the dented metal watering can, the dirt packed under my fingernails.
On the tape, Grandma asked if I’d remembered to water my flower.
“Yes.”
“How much?”
“A lot.”
“And how much is a lot?”
A long pause.
“All the water.”
Grandma made a sound that was suspiciously close to a cough. Then she burst out laughing. “Oh, Shannon.“
The recording ended.
I sat there listening to the hiss of empty tape. Then I rewound it, just to hear her laugh again. I played it twice. On the third time, I noticed something.
Grandma never corrected me. Not once. She just kept asking another question. And another. And I kept answering every one.
I flipped the cassette over. SIDE B.
This time the silence lasted longer before she spoke. Her voice was older now. A little rougher.
“Shannon, sweetheart. I hope that made you laugh.”
I pressed my hand over my mouth.
“Your grandfather made that recording when you were little. He thought it was hilarious that you could talk about one flower for twenty minutes.” A chair creaked. “I never did figure out what those purple flowers were called.”
She paused.
“There’s something I should have told you a long time ago.”
I leaned closer to the speaker.
“When you were six, I overheard you talking to your mother. You told her you thought people liked you better when you were quiet.”
I frowned. I didn’t remember ever saying that.
“Children say all sorts of things,” Grandma went on. “But I remember wondering why my granddaughter already believed she had to make herself smaller for people. So the very next weekend, I asked you to help me plant flowers.”
I looked toward the window.
“You talked the entire afternoon. About your teacher. Your shoes. A bird you saw. And those purple flowers.” She chuckled. “I don’t believe I finished a single sentence.”
I could see her so clearly. Kneeling beside the garden bed. Letting me drown the poor flower. Listening to every word.
“You always thought you came over to keep me company,” she said softly. “That’s not how it started, dear. I liked having someone who wanted to talk to me. And I liked that, with me, you never seemed afraid of saying the wrong thing.”
I sat back, stunned.
For years, I’d remembered those weekends as something I did for her. It had never occurred to me that she’d invited me because she thought I needed a place to be heard.
Then her voice changed.
“Now,” she said, “I need to tell you about something I got wrong.”
Part 2: The Confession on Side B
See more on the next page