NEIGHBORS HATED THE COLOR OF MY HOUSE AND SECRETLY REPAINTED IT GRAY WHILE I WAS AWAY FOR TWO WEEKS.
THEY THOUGHT THEY’D WON. THEY HAD NO IDEA I’D SPENT THIRTY YEARS AS A PARALEGAL — AND THAT THEIR NAMES WERE ALL OVER THE WORK ORDER.
PART 1
Neighbors hated the color of my house and repainted it while I was away — I was enraged, and I took my revenge.
My name is Eleanor, and my house sits on a corner lot in Cedar Hollow.
Two years ago, a newlywed couple — Blake and Tiffany Vance — moved in next door and immediately started making strange comments about my house’s yellow color.
Soon, they outright demanded I paint it something different.
My house has always been yellow. My late husband and I painted it that color thirty-one years ago, the summer we bought it. I love it, and there’s no rule against it.
They called the police and the city on me, but both told them to back off, since I hadn’t done anything wrong.
They even tried suing me — the suit got tossed, and they had to pay my legal fees — and they attempted to rally our neighbors into forming an HOA to force me to repaint.
Our neighbors told them to get lost, so now they’re alienated by everyone.
Then I had to go out of town for two weeks, to visit my daughter.
When I got back, my house was gray.
I almost drove right past it, because I’m so used to my yellow house.
The neighbor from across the street, a retired man named Walter, came over and showed me photos he’d taken of the painting company setting up and doing the work.
He and another neighbor had called the police, but the painting company had a valid work order and had been paid, so the police couldn’t do anything at the scene.
It seemed everything done to my house was technically legal, and no lasting damage had been done.
But I was enraged.
And I put my revenge plan into action.
What Blake and Tiffany didn’t know was that I’d spent thirty years as a paralegal before I retired.
And the work order they’d signed to paint someone else’s house without permission had their names all over it.
PART 2
Let me be clear about something up front, because it matters.
My revenge was not going to involve a single illegal act.
I’m seventy-one years old. I spent three decades inside the machinery of the law, watching people destroy themselves by doing something rash when the calm, correct, devastating option was sitting right in front of them.
Blake and Tiffany had spent two years doing rash things.
Calling the police (I did nothing wrong).
Calling the city (I was up to code).
Suing me (dismissed, with fees).
Trying to start an HOA (the neighborhood laughed them out of the cul-de-sac).
And now, finally, they’d done the rashest thing of all: they’d hired a company to paint my house — my house, which I own outright, on which they have no claim whatsoever — while I was out of town.
They thought they’d finally won, because the paint job was “done” and the police couldn’t un-paint a house at the scene.
What they’d actually done was commit several very clear civil wrongs and hand me the paperwork to prove it.
The morning after I got home, I did three things, in order, like the paralegal I am.
First, I got the work order.
Walter’s photos showed the painting company’s van and logo clearly. I called them — pleasantly, as a “homeowner following up” — and it took about four minutes to establish that Blake and Tiffany Vance had contracted and paid for the painting of the property at my address.
The company, it turned out, had done nothing wrong from their side; they’d been shown what they believed was authorization. When I explained, gently, that the people who hired them did not own the house and had no right to authorize anything, the office went very quiet, and then very cooperative, and then very willing to provide me a complete copy of the signed work order, the payment record, and Blake’s signature authorizing work on a property he didn’t own.
Second, I photographed everything. The gray house. The paint on my window trim they’d gotten sloppy with. The paint on a rose bush my husband planted. Every detail, time-stamped.
Third, I called an attorney — a former colleague, actually, from my paralegal days, who was delighted to hear from me and even more delighted to hear why.
“Eleanor,” she said, when I finished. “They painted your house. Without permission. And signed a document taking responsibility for it. Do you understand what you’re holding?”
“I do,” I said. “I held documents like it for thirty years. I just never thought I’d get to be the plaintiff.”
“Oh, we are going to have fun,” she said.
PART 3
Here’s what most people don’t understand about “revenge,” and what I understood after thirty years of watching it play out in courtrooms:
The best revenge isn’t loud. It’s correct.
Blake and Tiffany wanted a fight. They wanted me to scream, to key their car, to throw paint on their house in return — something they could then call the police about, something that would make me the aggressor, something that would finally, after two years, let them be the victims they so desperately wanted to be.
I gave them nothing to work with.
Instead, my attorney sent them a very calm, very professional letter.
See more on the next page